Lesson Plans > Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens?

Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens? Well the very brief answer to that question is YES and NO!  In this short lesson plan, we look at some of the latest evidence, and also at some simple tips to ensure that your phones become an enhancement, and not a detractor to your life.

25 Minute Lesson Plan

Objective 1: Watch Video or Listen to Podcast "Are Cell Phones Bad For Teens?"

Video: Are Cell Phones Bad For Teens?

Podcast: Are Cell Phones Bad For Teens?

  • Introduce topic by handing out One-Page Handout
  • Watch the Video or listen to the Podcast
  • Sugggest that students take notes on ideas that are of interest to them

Objective 2: Discuss the main points from the article and podcast, focusing on the following:

  • The rise of cell phone ownership and digital media use in relation to increasing rates of teen depression, anxiety, dissatisfaction with life, and loneliness.
  • The idea of being "forever elsewhere" when absorbed in one's phone.
  • The potential negative impact of cell phones on social engagement and connections.
  • Suggestions on how to ensure that cell phones don't become a source of toxicity, loneliness, and social awkwardness.
  • The importance of managing one's time and use of cell phones.

Objective 3: Quiz and Conclusion

  • Deliver Quiz
  • Summarize the key points discussed during the session.
  • Encourage students to think about their own cell phone usage and how it might be impacting their mental health and social connections.

Homework: Reflect on the discussion and come up with personal strategies to use cell phones in a manner that enhances, rather than detracts, from their lives.

One Page Handout

Main Points:

  1. Cell Phones and Mental Health: There has been a notable increase in depression, anxiety, dissatisfaction with life, and loneliness among teens in the last decade. This surge coincides with the rise in cell phone and social media usage.
  2. The 'Forever Elsewhere' Syndrome: Cell phones often make us mentally absent from our immediate environment. We're physically present, but our focus is on our phones. This contributes to feelings of isolation and social anxiety.
  3. The Power Is in Your Hands: You have the power to manage your cell phone usage and mitigate its negative effects. Here's how:
    A. Social Engagement: Foster quality relationships and social skills. Spend less time on your phone and more time interacting with others.
    B. Be Present: Engage fully in the moment. Avoid using your phone when you're in a social setting to prevent being 'forever elsewhere.'
    C. Create Your Own Adventures: Instead of watching others live their lives on social media, get out there and create your own memories.
    D. Use Your Phone Wisely: Use your phone as a tool for positivity and growth, not as a distraction from life.
    E. Set Boundaries: Limit your screen time and take control of your cell phone habits.
  4. Your Role in Solving the Crisis: It's up to you to manage your life and help others do the same. With self-awareness and effort, you can turn this crisis into a strength.

Remember: You have the power to manage your cell phone usage and its impact on your life. The goal is not to abandon technology, but to use it wisely and ensure it enhances, not detracts, from your well-being.

Quiz

1. What is the main question this article is trying to answer?

  1. How can we limit screen time for teens?
  2. Are cell phones bad for teens?
  3. How to use cell phones effectively?
  4. Why do teens love cell phones?

2. According to the article, when did the rate of depression in teens start to rise significantly?

  1. 2007
  2. 2011
  3. 2012
  4. 2019

3. What does the author suggest is the best way to use your phone?

  1. As a source of education
  2. As an enhancement, not a detractor or black hole
  3. To watch others have fun
  4. To stay connected with friends

4. What does the phrase "we are forever elsewhere" mean in the context of the article?

  1. We are always thinking about the future
  2. We are always physically moving from one place to another
  3. We are mentally absorbed in our phones, not present in the real world
  4. We are always dreaming about being somewhere else

5. What is the greatest predictor of long and short-term happiness, according to the article?

  1. Cell phone use
  2. Quality relationships
  3. Success in school
  4. Amount of friends on social media

6. How does the author suggest to make sure your phone doesn't become a source of toxicity and loneliness?

  1. By deleting all social media apps
  2. By placing self-limits, being more socially connected, and using the phone as an enhancement
  3. By switching to a basic, non-smart phone
  4. By only using your phone for calls and texts

7. What does the author suggest as a reason why phones are addictive?

  1. They are attractive, obvious, easy, and pleasurable
  2. They have a lot of fun games
  3. They allow for constant communication with friends
  4. They are a status symbol

8. What is the author's final call to action for teens?

  1. To throw away their cell phones
  2. To limit their screen time to one hour a day
  3. To stop using social media
  4. To manage their cell phone use wisely, and to use it as an enhancement to life

Answer Key

1. b) Are cell phones bad for teens?
2. c) 2012
3. b) As an enhancement, not a detractor or black hole
4. c) We are mentally absorbed in our phones, not present in the real world
5. b) Quality relationships
6. b) By placing self-limits, being more socially connected, and using the phone as an enhancement
7. a) They are attractive, obvious, easy, and pleasurable
8. d) To manage their cell phone use and contribute to solutions for the mental health crisis

Summary

Hey there, awesome people! You know, I've been pondering over this question: "Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens?" And guess what? The answer isn't as simple as we'd like. It's a YES and a NO! Now, don't get all jumpy and defensive, I'm not about to launch a crusade against your beloved phones. I'm just here to share some info, and then the choice is yours.

Look at the facts, my friends. Teen depression has doubled between 2011 and 2020. Suicide rates? Doubled between 2007 and 2019. Teens are feeling more unhappy, dissatisfied, and lonely. And this shift seems to coincide with the rise of smartphone ownership. Starting from 2007, by 2012, half of the world owned a phone. Today, 9 out of 10 teens have cell phones. Now, we can't say for sure that phones are the sole cause of all this, but it seems there’s a connection.

Let me share a quick story. I once took 400 teens on a 3-day camping trip, no phones allowed. The laughter and chatter were amazing! Compare that to a recent car drive with a bunch of teens, all glued to their phones. Silence. Each in their own little world, missing out on the real world.

And that's the rub. When you're in your phone, you're elsewhere. Your mind, your focus, is not here, not in the now. And that's a surefire way to feel miserable. But hey, don't lose hope. I have faith in you. You can tackle this problem and find solutions that work for you.

Here's a few tips: strive to be more socially engaged and connected. The greatest predictor of happiness is quality relationships, not how many likes you get on your latest post. Be where your feet are. Engage in the real world, turn off the notifications, look up and be present. And create your own fun, adventure, memories, and skills. Stop watching others have fun and start having fun yourself!

Use your phone wisely. Make it an enhancement, not a distraction. And set some limits. Phones are addictive because they're attractive, obvious, easy, and pleasurable. But you have the power to manage it, instead of letting it manage you.

So come on, raise your game! Don't make excuses or get defensive. Look at this challenge and do the work. Because, my friends, this is your generation's crisis. It's in your hands. But I'm confident you'll find ways to turn this into a strength. Let's do this!

TL;DR

Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens? The answer is both yes and no. Cell phone use among teenagers has increased dramatically in the last decade, coinciding with a rise in depression, anxiety, and feelings of loneliness. However, it's hard to definitively say cell phone use is the cause of these issues, as many factors can contribute to a teenager's mental health. I've observed that heavy cell phone use can lead to social isolation. The solution is not to eliminate phones but to use them more wisely. Tips for healthier phone use include being more socially engaged in person, being present in the moment (where your feet are), creating your own fun and memories, and using phones as an enhancement, not a distraction. It's also critical to set limits on screen time. In summary, while phones can have negative effects, they are not necessarily the problem. The key is how they are used. I am hopeful that today's teens can navigate this challenge and turn it into a strength.

Additional Materials

Here are some related articles that might be useful for you. They provide more context and different perspectives on the topic. Here they are:

Reading these articles will not only broaden your understanding of the topic but also help you form your own opinion. Remember, knowledge is power!

Individual Activities

1. Reflective Writing Exercise
"Take a few moments to think about your own relationship with your cell phone. How many hours do you spend on it each day? Do you feel it has more positive or negative effects on your life? Write a short paragraph reflecting on these questions. This will help you understand your current usage and its impacts."

2. Role-Play Activity
"Let's try to step into someone else's shoes for a moment. Imagine you are a friend, parent, or teacher who is concerned about a teenager's excessive cell phone use. What would you say to them? How would you express your concern without sounding judgmental or imposing? Write a short dialogue or monologue expressing this."

3. Action Plan Creation
"Based on what you've learned from the article and your own reflections, create a personal action plan to manage your cell phone usage better. This could include setting specific time limits for usage, designating certain times as 'phone-free zones', and finding offline activities that you enjoy. Write down your plan and think about how you can implement it in your daily life."

These activities aim to help students think more critically about their cell phone usage and its potential implications on their mental health, and also encourage them to take proactive steps towards healthier habits.

Group Activity

Materials needed: Copies of the article, paper, pens, and a timer.

Step 1:
I'll distribute a copy of the article "Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens?" to each student. I'll ask them to read the article individually and underline or make note of the points that resonate with them, especially the tips given towards the end about how to make their cell phone usage more healthy and beneficial.

Step 2:
After everyone has finished reading, I'll form groups of 4-5 students. Each group will get a piece of paper and a pen. I'll then set the timer for 5 minutes and ask each group to discuss within themselves the points that stood out to them.

Step 3:
Once the discussion time is over, I'll ask each group to write down their collective thoughts on the paper provided. They should answer two questions: 1) What was the most surprising point you learned from the article? 2) Which tip do you think will be the most beneficial for you to implement in your life and why?

Step 4:
After everyone has finished writing, I'll give each group a chance to share their answers with the class. This will open up a broader discussion and allow for different perspectives to be shared.

Step 5:
To conclude the activity, I'll encourage each student to choose one tip from the article to implement in their life over the next week. They can write this commitment down on a sticky note to place somewhere they'll see it every day as a reminder.

By the end of this activity, I hope that each of you will not only have gained a deeper understanding of the impact of cell phones on teen mental health, but also have a practical step to take towards better managing your screen time.

Homework

Hello, students and parents (or guardians)! Today, we're going to embark on a short activity based on the article we recently discussed, "Are Cell Phones Bad for Teens?" This activity aims to encourage a healthy balance between digital device usage and real-world interactions. It's a great chance to open up a dialogue about the role of cell phones in our lives.

Materials Needed: Paper, pen, and a willingness to communicate!

Step 1: Personal Reflection (5 minutes)
Start by taking a few minutes alone to reflect on your personal cell phone usage. Jot down the positive and negative impacts you feel your phone has on your daily life. Ask yourself questions like, "How much time do I spend on my phone?" and "What activities on my phone bring me joy and which ones cause me stress?"

Step 2: Sharing Reflections (5 minutes)
Now, come together and share your reflections. As a teen, discuss your thoughts with your parents or guardians. As a parent or guardian, share your perspective as well - remember, this is a two-way conversation!

Step 3: Brainstorming Solutions (5 minutes)
After sharing, it's time to brainstorm together. Discuss ways you can all help each other to maintain a healthier balance with your phone usage. Maybe you can decide on certain "phone-free" times during the day, or perhaps you can commit to putting away phones during meal times to foster more face-to-face interaction.

This activity is not about placing blame or making anyone feel guilty about their phone usage. Instead, it's about understanding the impact of our digital habits and working together to create a healthier balance. Remember, the best solutions will come from open, honest conversations and mutual understanding. Enjoy this time together and use it as a stepping stone towards a healthier relationship with technology.